Cast
Cara Buono
Kathleen Savio
James Karen
Pastor Tom Keller
Ryan Sands
State Detective Rogers
Harrison Forsyth
Justin Peterson
Wesley Thompson
Principal
John Asher
Neighbor Brad
Mike Carlucci
Jay the Disc Jockey
Larry King
Self (archive footage)
Teddy Sears
Mike Adler
Gordon Greene
Jasper
James Ellis Lane
Officer Jim
Steve Tom
Newspaper Editor
Tom Yi
Medical Examiner
Dameon Clarke
State Detective Franklin
Rob Lowe
Drew Peterson
James C. Burns
Peter
Danielle Savre
Chloe Roberts
Stephane Nicoli
Boom Operator (uncredited)
केली क्वोकोह
Stacy Peterson
Catherine Dent
Karen Chojnacki
Krista Kalmus
Brianna Cales
Natalie Smyka
Lauren
Romy Rosemont
Sofia
Tanner Maguire
Zach Peterson
William Mapother
Glenn Levecke
Jonathan Scarfe
Jeff Aberdeen
Anderson Cooper
Self (archive footage)
Matt Lauer
Self (archive footage)
Meredith Vieira
Self (archive footage)