On Broadway

Joey McIntyre as Jack O'Toole Eliza Dushku as Lena Wilson Mike O'Malley as Father Rolie O'Toole Will Arnett as Tom Andrew Connolly as Uncle Pete Jill Flint as Kate O'Toole Sean Lawlor as Martin O'Toole Lucas Caleb Rooney as Neil Quinn Peter Giles as Barry Cook Amy Poehler as Farrah