Cast
Wyatt Cenac
Babatunde
Jason Ritter
Julian
Michael Oberholtzer
Cody
Beau Sia
Hipster Guy
Meredith Hagner
Katelyn
Jake Cherry
Cory
Mela Hudson
Juli's Friend
Amy Sedaris
Crystal
Michael Cera
Bennie
Mario López
Extra Host
Ellen DeGeneres
Self (voice; uncredited)
Janet Krupin
Megyn McKibbens
Danny Flaherty
Christian
Jessie Ennis
Juli
Matt Walsh
Dave
Erinn Hayes
Maddy
Matty Blake
Officer Blauser
Derek Waters
Larson
Amy Carlson
Christina Casserta
Kurt Braunohler
Marshal
Rosemary Howard
Mrs. Torelli
Russ Tamblyn
Dale
Maria Menounos
Extra Host
James Adomian
Donovan
David Koechner
Rich
Julia Stiles
Woman at Dump