The Best Christmas Pageant Ever

Jenni Burke as Ms. Graebner Ray Strachan as Fireman Lorelei Olivia Mote as Alice Wendleken Vanessa Benavente as First Grade Teacher Stephanie Sy as Mrs. Thomas Judy Greer as Grace Bradley Matthew Lamb as Claude Herdman Danielle Hoetmer as Mrs. Wendleken Tom Young as George Armstrong Stanlee Arches as Ticket Taker Lauren Cochrane as Nurse Pond Adam Hurtig as Mr. Grady Zoe Fish as Choir Kid #1 Lauren Graham as Narrator / Adult Beth Bradley (voice) Beatrice Schneider as Imogene Herdman Sarah Constible as Mrs. Slocum Chloe McKinnon as Little One Molly Belle Wright as Beth Bradley Sebastian Billingsley-Rodriguez as Charlie Bradley Kirk B.R. Woller as Reverend Hopkins Elizabeth Tabish as Mrs. Grady Daina Leitold as Mrs. Hopkins Reena Jolly as Ms. Warren Isla Verot as Becky Pete Holmes as Bob Bradley

Dallas Jenkins Director, Executive Producer Gerald R. Molen Executive Producer Carmen Kotyk Casting Andrew Erwin Producer Jon Erwin Producer BJ Verot Stunt Coordinator Kevin Downes Producer Christopher Woodrow Executive Producer