Yes, God, Yes

Natalia Dyer as Alice Gabriella Garcia as Glue Girl John Teague as Extra Timothy Simons as Father Murphy John Henry Ward as Adam Susan Blackwell as Gina Parker Wierling as Wade Matt Lewis as Dad Allison Shrum as Heather Paige Hullett as Fiona Wolfgang Novogratz as Chris Teesha Renee as Beth Francesca Reale as Laura Tre'len Johnston as Andrew Christian Adam as Student #1 Paige Blackcloud as Extra Billy Grimm as Extra Donna Lynne Champlin as Mrs. Veda Myles Alexander Evans as Student #2 Carey Van Driest as Mom Riley Hough as Student #3 Kimberly Gonzalez as Extra Alisha Boe as Nina

Todd Antonio Somodevilla Director of Photography Sophie Mas Executive Producer Karen Maine Director, Writer, Executive Producer Ian Hultquist Original Music Composer Sara Sometti Michaels Assistant Production Coordinator Delphine Perrier Executive Producer Rodrigo Teixeira Producer Marcelle Coletti Stunts Sally Levi Production Design Chris Columbus Executive Producer Arianne Fraser Executive Producer Eleanor Columbus Producer Erica Arvold Local Casting Jordan Blair Mangold Brown Extras Casting